Grant advises waiting for the Commission process; parallel transport assessment requested
Grant McCallum acknowledges that the community’s concerns extend beyond fares to affordability, reliability and the ferry’s role as an essential transport link. He advises that the matter has been raised with Minister Brewer and a response is pending regarding a possible Commerce Commission investigation.
Grant’s position is to await clarity on the Commission’s position and the outcome of any investigation before progressing discussions with NZTA and other agencies.
Our response asks why the wider transport assessment cannot progress in parallel. It reiterates that the case for recognising the crossing as an essential transport link does not depend on demonstrating excessive profits, and seeks support for assessment without a commitment to a subsidy or particular funding outcome.
We have also requested the expected timing of Minister Brewer’s response, the next step if the Commission declines to investigate, and copies of correspondence for the public record. We are seeking a deputation to FNDC’s Transport and Infrastructure Committee.
A Commerce Commission investigation and a wider transport assessment have not been confirmed.
Clarification sent, 22 October: We have acknowledged that Grant’s 5 October letter to Minister Brewer was already supplied. Our request for copies refers to any further correspondence or separate written approach to the Commerce Commission. The other questions in our response remain.
The correspondence below is reproduced from the emails supplied by Karin. Grant’s reply was sent at 7:49 pm on 21 October. Office contact details, signature graphics and the repeated earlier email chain are omitted. The preceding 19 October email is available below.
Grant McCallum’s reply — 21 October 2026
Good evening Karin,
Thank you for your email. I acknowledge that the community's concerns extend beyond ferry fares to the broader issues of affordability, reliability and the ferry's role as an essential transport link.
As discussed at our meeting, the first step is to establish whether an investigation by the Commerce Commission is warranted. We have raised the matter with Minister Brewer and are awaiting a response regarding the possibility of an investigation.
I believe it is important that we follow this process before progressing discussions with NZTA and other agencies. Any approach to these agencies is likely to raise questions about what has been considered by the Minister and the Commerce Commission, and what conclusions, if any, have been reached.
Once we have clarity on the Commerce Commission's position, and the outcome of any investigation should one proceed, we can review the findings and determine the appropriate next steps in addressing the wider transport issues you have raised.
I recognise the considerable time and effort that you and others in the community have put into gathering the background information and supporting evidence. This will remain valuable as we work through the process.
Regards
Grant
Our response to Grant McCallum — 22 October 2026
Hi Grant,
Thank you for your reply. Is there a specific reason the wider transport assessment needs to wait for the Commerce Commission’s findings, rather than progressing alongside them?
Our case for the ferry as an essential transport link and extension of the road network does not depend on showing that the operator is making excessive profits. The hardship accounts I’ve shared concern people who rely on this crossing for everyday life. Ferry costs also affect visiting family, tourists, tradespeople and the wider Russell economy.
I’m concerned these transport needs will remain on hold while the Commission process unfolds. I’m asking for support to have the question assessed, without seeking a commitment to a subsidy or any particular funding outcome.
Could you please confirm whether you would support progressing that assessment in parallel? I would also appreciate knowing when you expect a response from Minister Brewer and what the next step would be if the Commission declines to investigate.
Please also provide a copy of your correspondence with Minister Brewer and any written request to the Commerce Commission, including attachments, and confirm whether these may be published on the Across the Channel documents page. This will help us keep the community accurately informed.
If your support at this stage is limited to the Commerce Commission approach, I’d appreciate knowing that clearly so we can pursue the wider question through other channels. In the meantime, we are seeking a deputation to FNDC’s Transport and Infrastructure Committee.
Kind regards,
Karin
Our clarification to Grant McCallum — 22 October 2026
Hi Grant,
Apologies—I already have your 5 October letter to Minister Brewer. I overlooked that when asking for a copy. That request should have referred to any further correspondence or separate written approach to the Commerce Commission.
The other questions in my email remain, particularly why the wider transport assessment needs to wait and whether you would support progressing it in parallel.
Kind regards,
Karin